Fire and Water Make Steam - Redefining the Role of Competition Law in TRIPS
Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Book chapter › Research › peer-review
Standard
Fire and Water Make Steam - Redefining the Role of Competition Law in TRIPS. / Schovsbo, Jens Hemmingsen.
Intellectual Property Rights in a Fair World Trade System: Proposals for Reform of TRIPS. ed. / Annette Kur. Cheltenham, UK / Northampton, MA, USA : Edward Elgar Publishing, 2011. p. 308-358.Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Book chapter › Research › peer-review
Harvard
APA
Vancouver
Author
Bibtex
}
RIS
TY - CHAP
T1 - Fire and Water Make Steam - Redefining the Role of Competition Law in TRIPS
AU - Schovsbo, Jens Hemmingsen
PY - 2011
Y1 - 2011
N2 - The paper points out the relevance of competition law to international issues of Intellectual Property Law (IPR) and demonstrates how competition law internationally has come to function as an indispensable instrument to balance IPR. The perspective is international and focused on TRIPS. The rules in TRIPS which define the obligations of member states to protect rightholders are detailed, comprehensive, and aimed at a high level of protection. The few rules in the Treaty which deals with competition law and the role of competition as a balancing instrument to IPR are weak and imprecise. This disparity does not reflect the conclusion in national law where it is now generally acknowledged that IPR and competition law serve the same goal, viz. dynamic efficiency and consumer welfare and where competition law has come to function as a second tier of balancing norms. The paper claims that the weakness of the competition rules in TRIPS may be counterproductive towards the broader goals of IPR protection. From a development point of view it is pointed out that an effective and well function market is necessary in order for developing countries to reap any benefits arising out of IPR protection. To innovation it is submitted that IPR protection e.g. of interfaces or in markets characterised by network effects may involve risks of monopolisation which require access to effective rules of competition law. The paper finally recommends concrete changes to TRIPS in the form of mandatory rules which prevent abuse in licensing contracts and a rule which makes it possible to gain access to IPR which is indispensable for competition.
AB - The paper points out the relevance of competition law to international issues of Intellectual Property Law (IPR) and demonstrates how competition law internationally has come to function as an indispensable instrument to balance IPR. The perspective is international and focused on TRIPS. The rules in TRIPS which define the obligations of member states to protect rightholders are detailed, comprehensive, and aimed at a high level of protection. The few rules in the Treaty which deals with competition law and the role of competition as a balancing instrument to IPR are weak and imprecise. This disparity does not reflect the conclusion in national law where it is now generally acknowledged that IPR and competition law serve the same goal, viz. dynamic efficiency and consumer welfare and where competition law has come to function as a second tier of balancing norms. The paper claims that the weakness of the competition rules in TRIPS may be counterproductive towards the broader goals of IPR protection. From a development point of view it is pointed out that an effective and well function market is necessary in order for developing countries to reap any benefits arising out of IPR protection. To innovation it is submitted that IPR protection e.g. of interfaces or in markets characterised by network effects may involve risks of monopolisation which require access to effective rules of competition law. The paper finally recommends concrete changes to TRIPS in the form of mandatory rules which prevent abuse in licensing contracts and a rule which makes it possible to gain access to IPR which is indispensable for competition.
KW - Faculty of Law
KW - CIIR
M3 - Book chapter
SN - 9781849800099
SP - 308
EP - 358
BT - Intellectual Property Rights in a Fair World Trade System
A2 - Kur, Annette
PB - Edward Elgar Publishing
CY - Cheltenham, UK / Northampton, MA, USA
ER -
ID: 33221625